** usual opening caveat: it is well beyond the scope of this short piece to address myriad pretexts and contexts and as such this represents one opinion aimed at ‘most people, most of the time’.
The hexbar deadlift
The hexbar deadlift is an often overlooked, underappreciated exercise which is suitable for many more people than it gets credit for. Myself and my friends and colleagues have used this exercise extensively with a full spectrum of clients for many, many years. Now, just to be clear, I don’t have any issues whatsoever with the more traditional straight bar deadlift; it’s a fantastic exercise for many reasons…. but… the hexbar (often referred to as a trap bar) presents us with an option which for many people, is safer, more appropriate and requires less time to perfect.
Let’s begin with hip motion. The internet provides us the endless debate as to whether the deadlift is a back exercise or a leg exercise. In fact, it is said that the hieroglyphic characters discovered inside Tutankhamun’s tomb meaning ‘leg’ and ‘back’ are both represented by the depiction of a deadlift. Suffice it to say, this is not a new debate. My response to this question is that the deadlift is a hinge exercise. The hinge occurs at the hip. When the load (barbell/hexbar/kettlebell etc) is held in the hands the hinge motion comes from the hips and legs and the load is supported and maintained by the back and as such it is BOTH a leg and back exercise. How people choose to include deadlifts in their program is another debate entirely and ultimately depends on many individual factors; that’s definitely one for another day. The important point for today is that the movement occurs at the hip. With that in mind, the further forward the load is, the greater the sheer force experienced by the spine, in particular the lumbar spine. Whilst the lumbar spine is capable of withstanding sheer force (force transmitted across the spine), those large, wide vertebrae are most suited to withstanding axial load i.e load transmitted vertically down the spine as opposed to across the spine. In short, the hexbar exposes the lumbar spine – and the hip - to less stress because the weight is closer to the side and not as far forward out in front of the body. For most people, that’s a plus.
Technical advantages
Most of us in the gym/rehabilitation setting aren’t competitive powerlifters. With that in mind, the hexbar deadlift offers us a lift which utilises upper body mechanics which are closer to that which we find familiar in our daily use. Consider carrying several bags of heavy shopping on either side having picked them up from close to the sides of your body. That’s fairly close to the hexbar. The hexbar deadlift also requires a more upright torso than a conventional deadlift which could help to negate some of the risk of ‘rounding’ of the spine often associated with a poorly executed deadlift. These factors potentially make the hexbar deadlift easier to learn and safer to perform for most people. In addition to this, if the worst was to happen and something did go wrong, the hexbar offers a safer option to abandon mid lift due to the shape of the bar offering a safer space for the lifter to remain unaffected by the falling bar when compared to the straight bar which is more likely to contact with the lifter’s legs during a direct vertical drop to the floor. One other notable advantage to the hex bar is that many recreational lifters make rather a mess of ‘finishing’ the deadlift by hyperextending the low back without managing to achieve full hip extension. This is an area the hexbar offers greater ease due to the fact that at the terminal point of the lift the bar is still being lifted ‘upwards’ and not being pulled ‘upwards and inwards’.
Considerations
It is, of course, certainly not perfect and many people performing deadlifts are doing so with a view to working the hip and posterior chain of muscles and the hexbar does transfer more of the effort to the quadricep muscles than a traditional straight bar deadlift. This could be overcome using supplementary barbell hip thrusts or even the Glute Ham Developer.
In summary, the hexbar offers several advantages for most people who have the desire to lift relatively heavy weights from the floor in a safe and relatively easy-to-learn way. Why not add it into your programs or at least give it a go and see what you think.
I hope that helps.
Remember: pain doesn't always mean STOP but it's a good idea to PAUSE until you find out what it does mean, just in case.
© Crescent Health and Fitness 2022
Abbeydale Squash and Fitness Club
Abbeydale Road South
Sheffield
S17 3LJ